You found your way out of The Mind’s Eye, and Lilith had saved you while also allowing you to sever the bond you had with Mephisto, but the cost was dire.
With Lilith now gone and your bond severed from Mephisto, it is time to move on and search for Lorath, who has wandered off in search of help while you were unconscious.
You and Tyrael will need to make haste as Lorath’s life is on the line, and it is uncertain what may happen if he is out there on his own.
How To Get One Eye Closes, One Eye Opens Quest?
The “One Eye Closes, One Eye Opens Quest” becomes available once you have completed the “Death” quest, where you recently got trapped in The Mind’s Eye.
With Lilith’s help, you were able to escape and get out, but this also involved you having to stab Lilith with the reforged blade.
One Eye Closes, One Eye Opens Walkthrough
Now that you are reunited with Tyrael, the two of you must make your way to The First Vault’s entrance to seal it, but this also requires you to fight your way past enemies.
Move to the marked area, and lava golems will appear, which you will need to defeat before the two of you can continue.
Continue fighting your way through the monsters that have made their way into the Vault until you eventually reach the entrance.
Speak to Tyrael, and he will begin to seal The First Vault to prevent other enemies from making their way inside.
You will have to protect Tyrael while he is channeling his magic to seal it, which requires defeating all the waves of enemies that appear.
Once the entrance has been sealed, speak to Tyrael once more, and after your conversation, the quest will come to an end.
One Eye Closes, One Eye Opens Quest Rewards
After Tyrael has sealed The First Vault and you have spoken to him, the quest will end, causing a new one called “The Fools” to begin.
In addition to the next quest being unlocked, you also receive:
- XP
- Gold
Verdict
After you returned from The Mind’s Eye, it became clear that enemies had already breached The First Vault in your absence, forcing you and Tyrael to push through and clear them out.
With the area finally secured, Tyrael sealed the vault to prevent any further intrusions, ensuring the Horadric site remains protected from lingering threats.
Now that the situation inside is under control, your attention turns to Lorath, who is still unaccounted for and likely somewhere nearby after splitting off during the chaos.


